Learn how to make these easy Toll House Cookies in the Air Fryer using refrigerated cookie dough.

If you prefer to make your cookie dough homemade, be sure to try this recipe for Air Fryer Chocolate Chip Cookies using homemade dough.

In this post, I am going to focus on using refrigerated dough with Nestle Toll House Cookie Dough. This classic cookie was probably a staple in most of our childhoods, now it’s easy to bake up in your Air Fryer.

Tips for Making Toll House Cookies in the Air Fryer:

It’s best to use parchment paper to fit in your Air Fryer, in this case, I simply cut parchment paper to fit. I find though that this parchment paper works the best that has holes in it so that the air circulates evenly on the bottom.

It will fit nicely on the bottom, then simply break apart each cookie and place it evenly in the basket of the air fryer. This was done in batches in my Ninja Foodi Air Fryer because I could only fit 9 at a time.

The benefit of this is, you can save the rest of the cookie dough if you are only wanting a few cookies and not a whole big batch. That means they will always be freshly baked and warm!

The next point to remember is the cooking time is EVERYTHING! All Air Fryers heat differently, even the same manufacturer of air fryer can put off a different amount of heat between the same exact machine.

That means it’s very important to watch the cookies closely the first time that you make these. The method I use is to bake them low and slow. This way they evenly bake.

Remember that the cookies will sit and cool in the air fryer for about 3-5 minutes and it will finish up the baking process even when the air fryer isn’t on.

Then it is a must to carefully remove them and place them on a wire rack to fully cool.

Can you use different varieties of cookies?

Any variety of Toll House Cookies can be made in the air fryer that means although I’m showing you chocolate chip, it works the same with sugar cookies and peanut butter cookies too!

This method will work with any refrigerated cookie brand such as Pillsbury too.